Check out our ZERO FILLER, GLUTEN FREE and KETO FRIENDLY Blue Crab Lump Crab Cakes!

Experience the coastal charm through our seafood delicacies

Just A Little About Us

As owner of Captain’s Choice Seafood Market, my commitment is to honor customers by offering many varieties of fresh local seafood based on what is available and with attention to customer requests and feedback. Captain’s Choice constantly investigates and presents customers with new seafood specialties to consider the potential for sales. This has led to the purchase of wild salmon which typically sells out early every week.  The determination to offer customers the very best blue crab lump crab cakes containing absolutely NO FILLER has recently resulted in overwhelming customer orders. I am not satisfied with the ordinary.  I strive to be an extraordinary seafood business! Your patronage is my greatest reward!

Zero Filler, Gluten Free and Keto Friendly Crab Cakes

Let’s Talk Crab Cakes

Our Premium Blue Crab Lump Crab Cakes, are specifically for individuals who desire the sweet taste of blue crab lump crab meat to be the star! Not diminished by other ingredients, including fillers, that overpower the essence of the crab cake. At approximately 3.5 ounces, this crab cake is moist and supported by carefully selected ingredients that complement the uniqueness of this one of a kind crab cake. At Captain’s Choice, you will find a variety of different style crab cakes.

Your Seafood Awaits You Today

Fresh Seafood Starts Here

If you crave fresh, flavorful, and downright delicious seafood, then it’s time to chart your course to Captain’s Choice Seafood Market! 🌊💥 We’re not just another seafood shop—we’re the top catch in town, thanks to our obsession with freshness, value, and top-notch quality! 🎯🐟 Whether you’re grilling, frying, or just dreaming of a seafood feast—Captain’s Choice is THE place for locals and visitors alike. Come see why everyone’s hooked! 🎣💙

Fresh Catch Gallery

Fresh, yellowfin tuna! Loins will be cut into steaks resulting in a sweet, mild, firm taste. With so many recipes to try, you have endless options to enjoy this great catch! Pictured is a poke bowl with our fresh Tuna.

Our Premium Zero Filler Crab Cake that is Gluten Free and Keto Friendly!

Soft Shell Crabs already cleaned and ready to cook! Fry until golden brown and the legs start to curl.

Sea Scallops, wild-caught in the Atlantic. These are fresh, dry-packed 10/20s, meaning their jumbo size is full of succulent, juicy meat!

Indulge in the savory delight of a Crab Pretzel, a delicious snack that combines the rich flavors of crab and cheesy goodness in every bite. Perfect for satisfying your cravings, this treat is a must-try for seafood lovers!

Jumbo Lump Fresh Picked NC Crab Meat

Show More

Gift Cards for Seafood Lovers

Not sure what to get a seafood lover? A Captain's Choice gift card is the perfect solution! You can choose from our wide selection of premium products.

Buy a Gift Card Now

Raving Reviews

Contact Us

Captain’s Choice

1046 Cedar Point Boulevard, Cedar Point, North Carolina 28584, United States

252-723-0600

Hours

Mon

Closed

Tue

Closed

Wed

11:00 am – 03:00 pm

Thu

11:00 am – 05:00 pm

Fri

11:00 am – 05:00 pm

Sat

09:00 am – 02:00 pm

Sun

Closed

Hours are subject to change. Please note that I am a one man operation and once we sell out for the day, we will tend to close. Give us a call to confirm.


Copyright © 2025 Captain’s Choice - All Rights Reserved.


Powered by

Welcome to the Seafood Market

Thank you for visiting my website. As you can see, nothing fancy here... just simple delicious seafood! Be sure to check out my ZERO FILLER Crab Cakes and Crab Pretzels! But wait... when you mention this post, you will get $2 OFF a pack of my signature Crab Cakes or a Crab Pretzel!

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

YES, I LOVE FRESH SEAFOOD